MarineBusiness-World.com
 
 
News Home FishingBoating Photo Gallery Australian Cruising Sail-World Australia
Sail-World.com : US Laser trademarks up for grabs?
US Laser trademarks up for grabs?


'Lasers at the 2013 ISAF Sailing World Cup Hyeres'    Thom Touw ©    Click Here to view large photo

The following opinion piece on Laser Trademarks up for grabs? has been provided by Improper Course, a blog which is a collection of the sailing education and adventures of two sailors, Doug Peckover and his wife Pam on opposite ends of the experience and success spectrum. It ranges from the Laser Master Worlds to the local Laser sailing as well as a couple of other dinghies and the occasional keelboat.

Pam writes 'I originally wrote this back in November but took it down the next day to wait for a more appropriate time.

As noted in my LaserPerformance United Unions post, it seems that Rastegar has quite the maze of confusingly incestuous entities. It appears that he lost track and the result is that he may very well have lost some of the trademarks for Laser, Sunfish, Vanguard, Zuma, Red Dragon and Nomad..

As best as we can tell, Quarter Moon Inc. d/b/a Vanguard Sailboats sold several trademarks to Karaya Holdings Limited, an Irish entity, which then transferred the trademarks to Karaya (Jersey) Limited, a Jersey Island entity.

Seems fairly straight forward except that some errors in the transfer to the Jersey entity makes it questionable that the last transfer is valid which leaves everything still in the name of the Irish entity which is now dissolved. Whether or not the errors can be papered behind to salvage ownership of the marks may have to be determined by a court of law.

So, to be specific on the errors, check for yourself. Here is the Vanguard to Karaya Irish assignment and here is the Karaya Irish to Karaya Jersey assignment.

Look closely at the supporting document of the second assignment. It’s just a name change from Karaya Jersey’s former name, Dorsal, to its current name. Did you catch the error? Who cares what the former name of Karaya Jersey is when it is Karaya Irish that owns the trademarks. Note that the assignment was trying to go from an Irish company to a Jersey company and submitted a Jersey name change as evidence of assignment.

Even the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) didn’t catch this error and incorrectly lists Karaya Jersey as the current owner.

     


So then, being curious, I pulled the publicly available paperwork for Karaya Irish to see if I could determine if they properly conveyed the trademarks to Karaya Jersey which would mean an easy filing with the USPTO to correct things.

What I found was that the paperwork did indeed list the conveyance to Karaya Jersey but they listed the transfer as of January 1, 2009. If you go back and look at the name change document they filed with the USPTO, you’ll see that the name change from Dorsal Irish to Karaya Irish didn’t happen until February 23, 2009. Meaning, it could maybe be argued that the trademarks were conveyed to an entity that wasn’t yet legally in existence.

But then the icing on the cake is that the Karaya Irish entity, which, at present, may be the last entity to hold clear title to the trademarks, was dissolved on October 22, 2010.

That might be a problem. Hard to paper behind something when the conveyance was hosed up and the entity that needs to correct it is dead.

Confused? Easy to see how they lost track of which door the trademarks were hiding behind. Doug drew the diagram above to make it simple. It didn’t help matters that they had two Karaya entities and two Dorsal entities, a pair of each in each country, and in Jersey one became the other but in Ireland they remained separate and then two were dissolved, leaving only one. That’s just plain jacked up.

The Laser marks owned by Karaya that are possibly up for grabs are in the classes of goods that include sailboats and sails. LP has another foreign entity, Velum Limited, that has owns the Laser marks that secures the class of services that includes regattas. And that registration is jacked up too (check it out here).

Most people have heard about the critically received eight year deal (view here) that LP secured with the US Inter-Collegiate Sailing Association to use LP manufactured boats exclusively for all national and semi-final college championships.

After securing such a deal, I predicted back in November that the ILCA would be influenced to go in the direction of following through with their fundamental rule change, which they did. I mean from a business point of view, LP has the Laser trademarks and the eight year exclusive deal with ICSA. That seems like a fairly strong bargaining position.

But, let’s think about this. If LP entities don't have clear title to the trademarks, can that be used to invalidate the 8 year exclusive agreement? And, really, LP doesn’t even own the trademarks. I mean, we all know that some how, some way, Rastegar is the ultimate owner but the ILCA’s fundamental rule change (rea here) indicates that the manufacturer has to have trademark rights. Legally, LP doesn’t own the trademarks but the ILCA doesn't elaborate on what 'trademark rights' means. But what if the Laser trademarks are totally up for grabs?

Then I found this very interesting post about why trademark holdings companies are a bad idea. Skip down to the section titled: Legal Pitfalls of Licensing through Trademark Holding Companies:

'One of the defenses mounted ... for invalidity is that the licensor holding company doesn’t exercise sufficient control over its licensees. Rather, they argued, control is exercised by the holding company’s parent corporation and the holding company has therefore made a 'naked license.' The remedy for a naked license is for the court to declare that the trademark in question was abandoned by the trademark owner.'

     


Hmmm...

Original article can be viewed on the Improper Course website


by Improper Course

  

Click on the FB Like link to post this story to your FB wall

http://www.marinebusiness-world.com/index.cfm?nid=109245

7:15 AM Wed 8 May 2013GMT


Click here for printer friendly version
Click here to send us feedback or comments about this story.

Click for further information on
2013 Bruce Kirby Inc vs PSE, ISAF, ICLA etc.,

Related News Stories:

08 May 2013  Laser Lawsuit - Challenge to Laser trademark ownership
06 May 2013  ISAF and ILCA on thin ice? Intellectual Property Rights and Copyright
01 May 2013  ISAF Laser intervention - Supply problems looming?
30 Apr 2013  Laser ISAF ILCA action brings expanded Bruce Kirby law suit
24 Apr 2013  It's the boat that matters, not the name
24 Apr 2013  Laser Legal tangles continue
24 Apr 2013  Statement from the International Laser Class Association
24 Apr 2013  ISAF Statement On International Laser Class
12 Apr 2013  Kirby Torch replaces Laser, production heads to Canada
11 Apr 2013  The Kirby Torch - Latest news after Laser lawsuit
MORE STORIES ...






Marine Business News







Volvo Ocean Race CEO Knut Frostad talks Time and Money (Part II) *Feature by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World team,
















Yamaha inspires students to succeed by Yamaha Motor Australia,






Volvo Ocean Race 2014-15 CEO Knut Frostad talks (Part I) *Feature by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World team,






Swan celebrates sales success *Feature by Jeni Bone,








Stealth i14 out of China by Neil Patchett,






















Volvo Team Vestas Wind skipper Nico says: 'We can win' - Part II *Feature by Rob Kothe and the Sail-World team,


Volvo Ocean Race Team Vestas Wind skipper - One Design is key *Feature
2014 National 4x4 Outdoors Show: Popularity of caravanning and camping
2015 Sydney Inte'l Boat Show - Boating Industry commences planning
Volvo Ocean Race - Danish entry confirmed as Team Vestas Wind
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 12 2014 - NZ Credit Card dead
Pacific Boating membership offers hassle-free boating *Feature
Marine15 expands trade, networking and B2B opportunities *Feature
2014 Auckland on the Water Boatshow - Huge prize packs up for grabs
Fire causes million dollar damage on HMAS Bundaberg
4X4 Outdoors Show and Fishing and Boating Expo wows water lovers
Volvo Ocean Race: Win a stopover trip by designing an ECsix T-Shirt
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 9 2014 - RBA confirms low rates
2014 Audi Hamilton Island Race Week: Last minute accommodation options
Sydney Int'l Boat Show - Stellar results for Multihull Solutions
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 8 2014 - Oz jobless jumps
NSW Environment Minister awards 'Fish Friendly' Marina Accreditations
PSP Southampton Boat Show - Don't miss the most exciting show ever
Doyle Sailmakers delivers sails to 60m Perini Navi Sloop Perseus 3
METS - New look and feel for SuperYacht Pavilion
Aurora to ship Riviera’s World Premiere to Fort Lauderdale
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 7 2014 - NZ UnEmployment drops   
Extreme Sailing Series and GAC Pindar extend logistics contract   
Elaine Fowler, RPAYC's first female life member elected   
Chief Executive Officer sought for Yachting Australia   
Refurbished Protector project 'better than buying new'   
Explore Australia Expo to return to Melbourne Showgrounds in 2015   
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 6, 2014 - Jawboning hits NZD   
Gold Coast International Marine Expo - High-Diver Steve Black is back   
4x4 Outdoors Show, Fishing and Boating Expo - Campfire cooking corner   
Serenity Marina offers a yacht sanctuary in southern China   
Collinson FX Market Commentary: August 5, 2014 - Equity markets jump   
Loads in store from the RYA at the PSP Southampton Boat Show   
Royal Prince Alfred Yacht Club’s Jack Gale training centre born   
See the heat with FLIR ONE *Feature   
John Temple to retire, Will Sangster appointed General Manager   
Multihull Central launches Aquila range at SIBS *Feature   
Dredging link to WA coral disease   
Cannes Yachting Festival - Come see the 55 meter Ocean Paradise   
Sun shines on recreational boating at Sydney International Boat Show   
Phuket Yacht Show: new kid on the block taking on PIMEX? *Feature   


For this week's complete news stories select    Last 7 Days
   Search All News
For last month's complete news stories select    Last 30 Days
   Archive News







Sail-World.com  


















Switch Default Region to:

Social Media

Asia

Australia

Canada

Europe

New Zealand

United Kingdom


http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/Twitter_logo_small.png http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/FaceBook-icon.png  http://www.sail-world.com/event_images/image/RSS-Icon.png

United States

Cruising Northern

Cruising Southern

MarineBusiness World

PowerBoat World

FishingBoating World

 

Contact

Commercial

News

Search

Contact Us

Advertisers Information

Submit news/events

Search Stories/Text

Feedback

Advertisers Directory

Newsletter Archive

Photo Gallery

 

Banner Advertising Details

Newsletter Subscribe

Video Gallery

Policies

 

 

 

Privacy Policy

 

 


Cookie Policy

 

 



This site and its contents are © Copyright TetraMedia and/or the original author, photographer etc. All Rights Reserved.  Photographs are copyright by law.  If you wish to use or buy a photograph contact the photographer directly.
XLXL VIR MBW
LocalAds   DE  ES  FR  IT